Monday, 5 November 2012

Garnier Olia Permanent Hair Colour Innovation – 4.6 Deep Red (review)

Garnier Olia Permanent Hair Colour Innovation
I saw this hair colourant on prominent display as it has only just been released, and as I'm always looking for something innovative, the idea of using a hair dye made without ammonia but with 60% natural oils appealed to me.

This particular dye has taken Garnier three years to develop and has twenty two patents pending, so it's clearly very advanced, and at just under £7 a pack seems well-priced, too. The lack of ammonia, which can be damaging to your hair, is great news and the natural oils in this dye will be more nourishing than regular water-based alternatives, so it's all looking good.

The most prominent oil used in the colourant and developer isn't flower-based at all, which is surprising when the packaging is emblazoned with a massive sunflower. It is, in fact, mineral oil – the flower oils are much further down in the ingredients listings. This is disappointing, but you have to bear in mind the damage dying your hair can do, so a more nourishing oil, even paraffinium liquidum, is better than nothing.

Sunflower © 2010 duchesssa
Garnier say that Olia will give you “maximum colour performance” and will “improve the visible quality of your hair” by making it potentially 17% shinier and up to 35% smoother. The application is “sensorial” - that's not a word you use everyday! – and the formula is non-drip with a floral scent. I'm pleased to say the instruction leaflet is very clear. It helps that only one language is included.

They describe two methods of application: the root touch-up and the all over colouring.  The shade I'm using here is 4.6 – Deep Red, which looks quite a bit darker than the previous dye I used: L'Oréal Paris Sublime Mousse Permanent Foam Colour – 740 Flaming Copper and is actually the shade Garnier are using in a lot of their advertising for Olia, as it's such a bold, fabulous looking colour.

When you open the box the containers are pretty big, but there's not a huge amount of developer and colourant, and infuriatingly I found that there wasn't enough formula to cover my hair! With every other hair dye kit I normally have some product left over, but to actually run out of dye is something that hasn't happened in over a decade of home hair dying, and now I'm left with small patches of hair at the back of my head which are the old colour!

This stinginess simply isn't good enough. It doesn't help that the rather thick consistency means it's more difficult to spread through your hair, unless it's very fine. The applicator bottle is also very disappointing, as it's shaped like a droplet (to represent a drop of oil, I presume) so while it looks quite stylish, it's very difficult to hold when it gets wet, and this makes application too troublesome. Style over substance springs to mind.

Garnier are true to their word regarding the fragrance – there really is no eye-watering ammonia smell. It smells floral, but even this isn't overpoweringly fragrant. The dye went very orange when developing on my hair, which did worry me a bit – I had horrible visions of looking like Vivienne Westwood! Thankfully when I started to rinse off after thirty minutes I found my hair was quite a bit darker (and pinker) than the dye itself.

Unfortunately, this is without doubt the most hard to rinse hair dye I have ever used. I must have spent a good ten minutes drenching my hair in water in an effort to remove the colourant. Even after conditioning and rinsing some more I was still squeezing dye from my hair. I actually gave up in the end when the water was tinged with just a little orange. Yes, my hair is fairly long and quite thick, and yes the colour I've chosen is a particularly intense shade of red, but there are limits to what I'm willing to put up with.  Fifteen minutes of non-stop rinsing shouldn't be necessary.

You do get more conditioner than some other hair dyes in this price bracket, so it's good for about three uses for long-haired people, and it's nicely nourishing. It's not as slick as some conditioners, but then my hair didn't feel particularly dry after dying it, so it doesn't need to be. The gloves aren't great, to be honest; they're certainly big enough but they're thin and feel like black bin liners.

This dye really does leave me feeling conflicted. On the one hand it's ammonia-free, which I appreciate. It doesn't have that dreadful smell that most dyes suffer from, and it's genuinely kinder to your hair. The plant oils (and mineral oil) have left my hair feeling softer and it looks nice and shiny.

The colour is bold and mostly even but does lack the natural tones and highlights of the very best dyes. If Garnier can improve the applicator bottle design, include quite a bit more formula and make the intense colours easier to rinse out then I'd highly recommend this dye to everyone (even though it's not one of the great new foaming dyes!).

As it is, even with the benefit of being ammonia-free and nourishing, there are just too many compromises. It's not even good value if you have to buy two boxes for longer hair. A disappointing kit.

And another thing...

I've now shampoo'd twice since dying my hair and I am still rinsing colour out of it!  I've never had so much trouble rinsing out a hair dye before.  Please be careful when choosing this particular shade, it's proving troublesome.

No ammonia – good for hair and wellbeing!
Lots of paraffinium liquidum
Easy to understand instructions
Not good value if you need two boxes for longer hair
Nourishing oils make hair feel soft after use
Very stingy with the product

Badly designed bottle is difficult to hold

Extremely difficult to rinse all the dye out


Brand: Garnier


Developer Size: 60 g
Colourant Size: 60 g
Conditioner Size: 54 ml

Treatment Price: £6.99 (£6.99/treatment)

Manufactured: Belgium

Developer Ingredients: Aqua (Water), Paraffinium Liquidum (Mineral Oil), Cetearyl Alcohol, Hydrogen Peroxide, Steareth-20, PEG-4 Rapeseedamide, Tocopherol, Sodium Stannate, Polyquaternium-6, Pentasodiumpentetate, Phosphoric Acid, Tetrasodium Pyrophosphate, Hexadimethrine Chloride, Glycerin (F.I.L. C42424/1)

Colourant Ingredients: Paraffinium Liquidum (Mineral Oil), Aqua (Water), Ethanolamine, Steareth-20, Caprylyl/Capryl Glucoside, Polysorbate 21, Steareth-2, 1-Hydroxyethyl 4,5-Diamino Pyrazole Sulfate, 4-Amino-2-Hydroxytoluene, 5-Amino-6-Chloro-o-Cresol, Ascorbic Acid, Sodium Metabisulfite, Thioglycerin, Toluene-2,5-Diamine, Polyquaternium-67, Helianthus Annuus Seed Oil (Sunflower Seed Oil), 2-Methyl-5-Hydroxyethylaminophenol, Limnanthes Alba Seed Oil (Meadowfoam Seed Oil), Camellia Oleifera Seed Oil, Passiflora Incarnata (Passiflora Incarnata Seed Oil), EDTA, Parfum (Fragrance) (F.I.L. C54587/1)

Conditioner Ingredients: Aqua (Water), Cetearyl Alcohol, Behentrimonium Chloride, Cetyl Esters, Trideceth-6, Chlorhexidine Digluconate, Amodimethicone, Isopropyl Alcohol, Citric Acid, Cetrimonium Chloride, Parfum (Fragrance) (F.I.L. C53909/1)


  1. This stuff is the worst hair color I have ever used. Sure it looks good the first day, don't they all, but right off the bat my roots were 2 shades lighter. Now (2 weeks later) my hair is faded, limp, and thin. I hate it. Don't use it, you may have better results than I did, but don't take the chance - there are much better products on the market. Don't let the packaging and hype fool you!

  2. Even though I didn't suffer from all the problems you did, I agree that this hair dye was a massive disappointment. I'm glad to find someone else who agrees with me, as I read some reviews which were more positive than I was!

  3. Mineral oil is very damaging it thins the hair to get it back in good shape try www.hpospatrratments. com

  4. Ever since Ive used this dye my hair has been a greasy mess! I cannot stand it! Ive tried everything. It is a gray washed out greasy mess. NEVER USING AGAIN!

  5. Have you tried John Frieda Precision Foam Colour? That's my favourite; it's a very reliable colourant. :-)

  6. i fried my hair with too many dyes job and i just found out i have a medical condition that weakens my hair. i bought the "shielo restoration oil" and applied it 3 voila' my hair are back beautiful and silky like when i was a teenager and Im 47!

    While others like the smell, I do not ever like any smells - but its worth the results!

  7. I tried this is in dark intense auburn, which isn't a massive jump from what I had, the color is vibrant, I really like it and I've got lots of compliments on it, but I'm on day three and still washing out color! and trust me that first day I rinsed and rinsed and rinsed and I had to finally give up because it had been so darn long. I was glad to see at least I'm not the only one having this problem. I'm on day three and still see color coming out. In fact we stayed at a hotel this weekend and the room was hot so I got sweaty and woke up with pink spotted pillows! wtf? So we'll see what my hair looks like after it all rinses out :(

  8. Shielo Restoration Oil is not what it appears to be. The first four ingredients listed are in the PDMS family, polydimethylsiloxanes. This family of chemicals is basically window caulk, nutty putty or like Armorall. These are synthetic silicone substances that coat your hair to make it appear shiny and give the illusion of more body. They are viscoelastics that continue to slowly coat your hair over days. Basically, plastic hair.

  9. Thanks for all your input, guys! Kathy, you and I had almost identical experiences - it's put me off, personally! L'Oréal Feria is also very difficult to wash out, especially the red shades. Paul, you're quite right, I wouldn't use it, either!